Thursday, January 31, 2013
To Homeschool or Not to Homeschool
I don't have a direction in mind for this post, so it might come out nonsense, but I have been thinking about this topic almost non-stop. So here goes.
I have been a supporter of and personally interested in homeschooling for many years now - long before I was married. I definitely don't think it is the only way to do education, nor would I even say it is always the best way to do education. But, if done properly and a good fit for the family, I think homeschooling is brilliant and offers advantages that classroom schooling cannot.
But when it comes down to the reality of actually homeschooling our own children (a reality that is rapidly approaching, nay is pretty much already here!), I have been quite ambivalent.
Almost everything about the idea of homeschooling makes my heart thrill with excitement. Learning and exploring right along with my kids, flexibility and creativity, freedom to tailor learning to my kids' needs and interests, freedom to make use of a huge variety of resources in our community. Oh the freedom! And I feel so strongly about making education become part of a lifestyle, as natural as breathing, rather than something that is a segregated aspect of life (school). I don't want education to be something associated with dry textbooks and pop quizzes and being teased on the playground. I don't want the goal of learning to be a letter grade, I want it to be a reward unto itself.
BUT. Can I possibly do it? Do I really even WANT to homeschool my kids?
I worry that I will do an inadequate job of educating them.
I worry that my kids will drive me insane - I am definitely one of those moms who highly values regularly taking a break from my kid. The thought of having my days free again sooner rather than later sounds pretty amazing.
I worry that it won't even be an option financially because I will have to work in order for us to make ends meet.
Listen, I know, I KNOW, I don't have to have all those worries assuaged from the outset. We can start down the homeschooling path and if at any point it stops working, that's ok! It is not a forever, all-or-nothing, no-turning-back decision that must be made next week, or ever.
I also know so many kids who are educated in schools who are everything I hope my kids will be. I know that many schools can be and are amazing. I know that schools offer opportunities that homeschooling may not. I know that even if we do send our kids to school, we are not rendered helpless or utterly removed from their education - we can still find ways to make learning their lifestyle and not their weekday burden.
So, as to the immediate future - I had been researching preschools for Josiah for this fall. I am not doing that anymore. (For one thing, preschool ain't cheap.)(Besides, when looking at the curriculum of the 3-4 classroom of the closest preschool, it mostly consisted of skills he has already mastered!) (Proud mama.) There are at least two homeschool co-ops I know of that offer preschool aged activities that we can join this fall. And between that and the church nursery and friends and cousins to play with, he is getting plenty of socialization.
I am excited that we are going to start down the road with the intention of homeschooling him, always free to turn aside at anytime.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

12 comments:
We went to an open house last weekend for a gradeschool/preschool. It was there that my doubts that I can homeschool really took form. I have no idea if I will homeschool but it does not thrill me. I do know that they will probably not go to school until kindergarten. We will see. Thanks for this post!!
I was homeschooled for six years (5th grade - 10th grade) and there was a lot positive about it but of course a lot of messed-up weirdness about it. (The messed-up weirdness could not TOUCH the messed-up weirdness of my time at multiple Christian schools, but that's another topic altogether.) As an adult now and a parent, I know my parents were making the best decisions they could with the resources they had at the time but I do see so much fear of the world and public schools in their decision-making... Anyway, God used homeschooling in positive ways in my life but I don't strongly identify with the culture. I don't feel a call or an innate desire to homeschool my own kids, but I am open to it and for us, it's always an option on the table if other choices are not working out.
Mmkay, coming out of the corner as an occasional lurker here. I was home-schooled my entire life, and truly loved it. This will sound like a shameless plus, but I've written a TON about education and home-schooling on my various blogs. Plus, if you ever have any questions that you'd like to ask, my mom is a good one to approach, since she personally worked through all the home-schooling questions you wrote! We plan on home-schooling Harmony until/unless she asks for something else; there are plenty of co-ops, home-schooling groups, and other activities that will be available so that mom can have a day off ; )
Oops, I think I posted my comment three times. Now I don't see it. Hope I didn't spam you!
We went to an open house last weekend for a gradeschool/preschool. It was there that my doubts that I can homeschool really took form. I have no idea if I will homeschool but it does not thrill me. I do know that they will probably not go to school until kindergarten. We will see. Thanks for this post!!
yay, exciting! :D
My biggest motivation in even considering homeschooling is educational. I just honestly think that homeschooling best fits some of my strongly held beliefs about education and the formation of tines into adults. While I do want to be the primary influencer of my child when it comes to values and worldview, I have no desire or intention to overly shelter him or raise him with unrealistic ideas about the world. So I don't think fear is a motivator for me - but I totally hear what you are saying. And it's a good cautionary reminder.
I have no idea about homeschooling culture, or whether I would fit into it. I have seen a pretty wide variety of folks who homeschool - some are...interesting. But I have lots of friends who are doing it who don't really stand out in any other kind of identifiable way.
I already lurk your blogs, and never comment either! You/your mom will definitely be a resource I will consult when I have questions! :)
Surely you're already reading Homer's Iliad in Attic Greek with him, right? :P I think about this a lot too, and I don't have any children at all! I might just recommend some Alfie Kohn books ("Punished by Rewards" and "No Contest" ), also Ted Sizer's pair "Horace's Compromise" and "Horace's School" are worth the read, and I also really like Howard Gardner's new book "Truth, Beauty, and Goodness Reframed: Educating for Virtues in an Age of Truthiness and Twitter". All solid perspectives on "education" through which to view the question of home-schooling.
Thanks for the book recommendations! Will add them to my Goodreads "to be read" shelf. :)
Homeschooling has been great for us. All 3 of our kids went to preschool and that was a good experience for them, but it sounds like you have plenty of other options for giving yours early group socialization experience, other-adult input, etc. It can be a little bit challenging to be a homeschoolers who are Christian but who don't really fit the conservative Christian homeschooler stereotype (i.e. not necessarily right-wingers, not young-earthers, primary motivation is educational rather than sheltering from "the world"). We don't always feel comfortable in the local homeschool community writ large, but we have found other families here and there whose vision for homeschooling does match ours.
Sounds like you are thinking about it well, and offering all the sensible caveats, spotting possible pitfalls, realistic about the fact that you may not always be able to (or want to, or feel that it's best for your kids to) homeschool. Good luck to you. I linked to my wife's blog from my FB page a few days/couple of weeks ago. You might be interested to take a peek at it.
Have you read any of Susan Wise Bauer's writing on homeschooling?
No matter how often it happens, I'm always surprised when someone tells me that they read my blog! You should comment more often : ) I like the way you write!
Post a Comment